Nearly all liberal Bible colleges and seminaries, and sadly some which profess conservative evangelical doctrine, approvingly teach the ‘documentary hypothesis’, also known as the ‘JEDP hypothesis’.
What is the documentary hypothesis?
This is the liberal/critical view which denies that Moses wrote Genesis to Deuteronomy. It teaches that various anonymous authors compiled these five books (plus other portions of the Old Testament) from centuries of oral tradition, up to 900 years after Moses lived (if, in this view, he even existed). These hypothetical narrators are designated as follows:
The idea of multiple authorship of these books was first proposed by Jean Astruc in Paris in 1753. However, the foremost exponent was Julius Wellhausen (1844–1918), who ‘restated the Documentary Hypothesis … in terms of the evolutionary view of history which was prevalent in philosophical circles at the time’.1,2 He claimed that those parts of the Old Testament that dealt with sophisticated doctrine (one God, the Ten Commandments, the tabernacle, etc.) were not truth revealed by the living God, but were ideas that evolved from lower stages of thinking, including polytheism, animism, ancestor worship, etc.3 Hence the ‘need’ to find or fabricate later authors. One of the main arguments was that writing had supposedly not been invented yet at the time of Moses.
Thus the documentary hypothesis undermines the authenticity of the Genesis Creation/Fall/Flood accounts, as well as the whole patriarchal history of Israel. It presupposes that the whole of the Old Testament is one gigantic literary fraud, and calls into question not only the integrity of Moses, but also the trustworthiness/divinity of Jesus (see point 5 below). No wonder the critics have embraced it so warmly!….
Continue Reading on creation.com
This entry was posted in Apologetics, Creation Compromises, History, Theology and tagged 2 Kings, Abraham, Adam, ancestor, animism, anonymous, archaeological, Ark, authenticity, authors, authorship, babylon, Bible, biblical, camp fire, centuries, Christian, circles, clay, CMI, code, college, computer, conservative, contradictory, Covenant, creation, Creation Ministries International, Creator, critic, critical, customs, dead, deadly, death, Deuteronomy, divine, doctrine, documentary, editor, Egypt, Egyptian, Elohim, Elohist, evangelical, evolutionary, evolutionism, evolved, exile, Exodus, eyewitness, Fall, family, fauna, fellowship, fertile, Flood, Flora, foundation, fraud, Genesis, geography, German, God, governing, Hebrews, history, holiness, Holy Spirit, hypothesis, hypothetical, idiosyncratic, idolatry, inspiration, inventor, Isaac, Israel, Israelite, Jacob, Jahwist, Jean Astruc, JEDP, Jehovah, Jerusalem, Jesus, Jewish, Joshua, Julius Welhausen, kingdom, Law of Moses, leaders, legends, letters, liberal, lifetime, Lord, magazine, majesty, Middle Eastern, Millennium, monotheism, Moses, myths, narrators, nations, New Testament, Noah, northern, Old Testament, Omni, omnipotence, oral, Origins, Paris, passages, patriarchal, Pentateuch, philosophical, polytheism, Priest, rabbinic, region, religion, Revelation, revolution, Russell Grigg, savant, scholarship, secular, seminary, Seth, Shem, stage, tabernacle, tablet, Talmudic, taught, teach, Technion, temple, Ten Commandments, tradition, typewriter, university, view, worship, write, Yehuda Radday. Bookmark the permalink.